Alibi Murder Mysteries
The Case of the Missing Turkey cover art

Free sampler

The Case of the Missing Turkey

The turkey is gone. Everyone is hiding something.

  • 6 suspects
  • Unlimited investigators
  • 45 min
  • Easy difficulty
  • Host runs the game (doesn't play)

Themes: Cozy, Family-friendly, Thanksgiving

Share:PinterestFacebook

Thanksgiving at Grandma Jo Butterworth's house runs like clockwork.

Or at least Grandma Jo would like everyone to believe it does.

Every year, the Butterworth family gathers for the same traditions: too much food, an overly competitive backyard football game, unsolicited cooking advice, at least one minor family argument, and Grandma Jo's famous Thanksgiving turkey.

Dinner is served promptly at 4:00 PM.

At 3:20 PM, Grandma Jo opens the oven. The roasting pan is there. The turkey is not.

Six people were at the house. Everyone had an opportunity. Almost everyone is hiding something. And unless the Butterworths figure out what happened quickly, Thanksgiving dinner is about to consist entirely of side dishes.

A cozy, silly, family-friendly mini mystery for exactly 6 players. Easy, about 30–60 minutes.

The suspects

Grandma Jo Butterworth

The Thanksgiving Traditionalist

This is her Thanksgiving. She has hosted the Butterworth family for years, and dinner is at 4:00. Not 4:15. Four. O'clock.

Marty Butterworth

The Competitive Uncle

Has spent most of the afternoon organizing the annual Butterworth Backyard Bowl. Some people say he takes it too seriously. Those people are usually on the losing team.

Casey Butterworth

The Leftover Opportunist

Came to Thanksgiving prepared. Very prepared: reusable containers, aluminum foil and a suspicious number of zip-top bags. As far as Casey is concerned, there is nothing strange about this.

Riley Butterworth

The Vegetarian

Doesn't eat turkey, and has suggested for several years that Thanksgiving doesn't actually need one. That opinion has not aged well now that the turkey is missing.

Jamie Butterworth

The Aspiring Food Influencer

Has been documenting Thanksgiving all day: the decorations, the food, the family, and the "candid moments" that usually have to be redone.

Pat Butterworth

The Helpful In-Law

Married into the Butterworth family, and has learned that the easiest way to survive a Butterworth Thanksgiving is to stay useful. Today, they volunteered to help wherever needed.

Unlimited investigators

Any extra guests join as detectives. They question suspects, examine evidence as it’s released, and make the final accusation.

Nothing to buy or set up

The whole game runs from everyone’s phones: invitations, character packets, evidence, accusations and the reveal. Printables are there if you’d like them, and everything else is just for fun.

Make it a party

Food, drinks, decor and music to match the story. All optional.

Food

  • The turkey that wasn'tServe turkey sliders or turkey-and-cranberry sandwiches, and keep the big platter covered with foil until the reveal.
  • A sides potluckMashed potatoes, stuffing, green beans and cranberry sauce. Everyone brings one.
  • A vegetarian main for RileyStuffed acorn squash or a mushroom wellington, so no one goes hungry if the turkey never turns up.

Drinks

  • Warm apple ciderWith cinnamon sticks. A slow cooker keeps it warm all game.
  • Cranberry spritzersCranberry juice and sparkling water with a sprig of rosemary.
  • Sparkling cider for the toastFor when the culprit is caught.

Decor

  • Fall tableLeaves, mini pumpkins and candles down the middle of the table.
  • The empty roasting panFront and center, with a single sprig of rosemary. It's the crime scene.
  • Place cardsWrite each character's name on a card so everyone knows who's who.

Music

  • Cozy fall acousticSoft acoustic covers while everyone arrives.
  • Football on muteA game on the TV in the background, for Uncle Marty.