Alibi Murder Mysteries
The Case of the Missing Birthday Cake cover art

$14.99

The Case of the Missing Birthday Cake

Two cakes. Zero actual crimes. One birthday disaster.

  • 7 suspects
  • Unlimited investigators
  • 52 min
  • Easy difficulty
  • Host can play a character

Themes: Birthday, Comedy, Customizable, Family-friendly

Share:PinterestFacebook

It's Guest of Honor's birthday! The decorations are up, the guests are arriving, and someone has apparently bought candles for an entirely different birthday.

Everything is going according to plan. Until the cake disappears.

Not just any cake: the beautiful, custom-ordered birthday cake has vanished, leaving behind an empty stand and a mysterious note: SORRY. IT HAD TO GO.

There's also a smaller vanilla cake somewhere, but nobody seems interested in explaining where that went either.

One guest is hiding leftovers. Another is planning a prank. Someone is building a cake topper out of craft supplies. And the birthday star's best friend seems unusually determined to find a cake that isn't even the birthday cake.

Complete birthday challenges, question your friends, uncover their ridiculous secrets, and solve the mystery before the candles burn down.

An Alibi Mini Mystery: a clean, silly birthday whodunit. The guest of honor plays themself (you enter their name and age), with 6 suspects and unlimited detectives. Nobody gets murdered. About 45 to 60 minutes, and the host can play too.

The suspects

Guest of Honor

Birthday VIP and Lead Investigator

It's their big birthday, and their cake has vanished. Plays themself, isn't a suspect, and holds the birthday checklist that unlocks everyone's secrets.

Kelly

Party Planner

Planned the whole party: decorations, cake order, candles, schedule. Perfectly organized. Mostly.

Charlie

Prankster

Loves birthdays, and loves birthday pranks more. Nothing mean. Just a little harmless chaos.

Jesse

Best Friend

Guest of Honor's best friend. Brings the same traditional birthday accessory, in the same BIRTHDAY SURPRISE bag, every single year.

Robin

Family Friend

Has known Guest of Honor long enough to remember some deeply questionable childhood decisions. Never without an instant camera.

Drew

Creative Friend

The friend everyone calls when something needs fixing. Can build almost anything out of tape and toothpicks.

Frankie

Snack Enthusiast

Came for the celebration. And the snacks. Mostly the snacks. Can't eat chocolate, so there's a special vanilla cake just for them.

Unlimited investigators

Any extra guests join as detectives. They question suspects, examine evidence as it’s released, and make the final accusation.

Nothing to buy or set up

The whole game runs from everyone’s phones: invitations, character packets, evidence, accusations and the reveal. Printables are there if you’d like them, and everything else is just for fun.

Make it a party

Food, drinks, decor and music to match the story. All optional.

Food

  • The cake(s)One chocolate, one vanilla. Check real guests' allergies.
  • Party snacksChips, popcorn, mini sandwiches: Frankie-approved.

Drinks

  • Birthday punchFruit punch with a scoop of sherbet.
  • Something bubblySparkling cider or soda, for the toast.

Decor

  • A cake tablePut a cake stand front and center. Empty is very on-theme.
  • Balloons and a bannerThe more birthday the better.

Music

  • Birthday party hitsUpbeat pop for arrivals; quieter during confessions.